The world of American Idol is buzzing with anticipation as the long-running reality singing competition gears up for its 24th season, set to premiere on ABC in 2026. However, one of the show’s most familiar faces, country music star Luke Bryan, has recently shared that he’s undecided about returning to the judges’ panel, while expressing confidence that fellow judge Carrie Underwood will likely reclaim her seat. This news, stemming from a candid interview with Taste of Country Nights, has sparked speculation among fans about the future of the judging trio, which also includes Lionel Richie and host Ryan Seacrest. As the show prepares to scout new talent, the uncertainty surrounding its judges adds an intriguing layer to the upcoming season.
Luke Bryan’s Hesitation and the Year-by-Year Decision
Luke Bryan, a staple on American Idol since its revival on ABC in 2018, has been a beloved judge for eight seasons. Known for his down-to-earth charm, heartfelt feedback, and ability to connect with contestants, Bryan has been a cornerstone of the show’s modern era. However, in his recent conversation with Taste of Country Nights, the “Buy Dirt” singer revealed that his return for Season 24 is far from certain. “Idol is kind of a year-by-year, ‘Do we do it or not?’” he stated, highlighting the fluid nature of his contract with the show.
Bryan’s uncertainty stems from the way Disney, ABC’s parent company, handles its decisions about the judging panel. He noted that the network is often “tightlipped” about its plans, leaving judges like himself and Lionel Richie waiting until the last minute to learn their fate. In a previous interview with Billboard in July 2024, Bryan echoed this sentiment, saying, “We currently haven’t heard what the story is on who’s coming back, and if Lionel and I are coming back. I think Disney is just trying to figure out what they want to do, and we’re just kind of sitting back and waiting until they decide.”
This lack of clarity seems to be a recurring theme, as Bryan’s contract, like Richie’s, is renewed on a yearly basis, keeping him in limbo about his long-term role.
Despite his apprehension, Bryan emphasized his love for the show and the joy he finds in mentoring young talent. “Last year was really, really incredible with Carrie and Lionel and Ryan,” he reflected, underscoring the camaraderie among the judges and host Ryan Seacrest. “The main thing is just, have fun with American Idol and have fun with the kids [contestants].” This positive experience, coupled with his eight-year tenure, suggests that Bryan’s hesitation may be more about logistical uncertainties than a lack of passion for the show. Still, his noncommittal stance has left fans wondering whether Season 24 could mark the end of his Idol journey.
Carrie Underwood’s Likely Return
In contrast to Bryan’s uncertainty, he expressed strong confidence in Carrie Underwood’s return for another season. Underwood, who joined the judging panel for Season 23 in 2025, replacing Katy Perry, brought a fresh perspective as a former American Idol winner. Having clinched the title in 2005 during the show’s fourth season, Underwood’s transition from contestant to judge was a full-circle moment that resonated with fans and contestants alike. According to Bryan, Underwood “really enjoyed” her first season behind the judges’ table. “I know she had a great time in the role,” he shared, adding, “My prediction would be highly favorable” when asked about her return for Season 24.
Underwood’s positive experience was echoed in her own comments during the Season 23 finale. Speaking to E!, she gushed about her time on the show, saying, “I had a lot of fun, for sure. I didn’t know how I’d feel about it, [but] Luke and Lionel, and the crew … the people that work on the show are just so easy to be around.” When pressed about returning, she responded, “That would be cool, I think,” leaving the door open for another season. Her enthusiasm, combined with her history with the show and her ability to offer insightful feedback, has made her a natural fit for the judging role.
Underwood’s tenure as a judge was marked by her empathetic approach and her ability to draw on her own Idol experience to guide contestants. Fans praised her for her constructive critiques and genuine support, which helped solidify her place on the panel. Bryan’s confidence in her return suggests that Underwood’s presence added significant value to the show, and her chemistry with Bryan, Richie, and Seacrest created a dynamic that resonated with viewers. As American Idol prepares for auditions, the likelihood of Underwood’s return seems to be a bright spot amid the uncertainty surrounding the judging panel.
The Judging Panel Dynamics and Season 23 Highlights
Season 23, which aired in 2025, was a standout for American Idol, largely due to the fresh energy brought by Underwood and the continued chemistry among the judges. Bryan described the season as “really, really incredible,” highlighting the fun and camaraderie among himself, Underwood, Richie, and Seacrest. The trio’s dynamic was a key factor in the season’s success, with Underwood’s perspective as a former contestant complementing Bryan’s and Richie’s veteran judging experience. Ryan Seacrest, the show’s longtime host, also played a pivotal role in maintaining the show’s warm, encouraging atmosphere.
The season saw Jamal Roberts emerge as the winner, a testament to the judges’ ability to identify and nurture talent. Underwood, in particular, garnered praise for her interactions with contestants, offering feedback that was both constructive and inspiring. Her journey from Idol winner to judge gave her a unique perspective, allowing her to connect with contestants on a personal level. Bryan and Richie, both seasoned judges, brought their own expertise, with Bryan’s country music background and Richie’s pop and R&B legacy creating a well-rounded panel.
Despite rumors of a feud between Bryan and Richie, which surfaced in some reports, Bryan’s comments suggest that the judging panel worked harmoniously. The focus remained on mentoring the contestants and creating a positive experience for both the performers and the audience. As American Idol prepares for Season 24, the question remains whether this successful dynamic will carry over or if the show will see a shake-up in its judging lineup.
The Financial and Career Considerations
One factor that may influence Bryan’s decision is the significant financial incentive of judging American Idol. Reports estimate that Bryan earns approximately $12 million per season, while Underwood’s salary for her 2025 season was estimated to be between $10 million and $12.5 million. These substantial figures reflect the show’s value to its judges, who are among the highest-paid personalities in reality television. However, for Bryan, the decision to return may also hinge on his busy music career.
With a catalog of hits that “perfectly walk the line between heartfelt and fun,” as described by Taste of Country, and ongoing tours, Bryan’s schedule is demanding. Balancing Idol commitments with his music and personal life could be a key factor in his year-by-year approach.
Underwood, too, has a packed career, having released nine albums and embarked on seven tours since her Idol win in 2005. Her net worth, estimated at over $100 million, reflects her success as one of the show’s biggest success stories. Beyond music, Underwood has ventured into acting, with a cameo in Cobra Kai Season 4 and reported ambitions to pursue more roles in Hollywood.
Her time on Idol has also given her a foothold in the entertainment industry, potentially influencing her decision to return. As a source told Star Magazine, “She’s spent time in L.A. doing American Idol and feels she’s got a better grip on the Hollywood acting scene now.” Whether Underwood sees judging as a long-term commitment or a stepping stone to other opportunities remains to be seen.
What’s Next for American Idol?
As American Idol gears up for Season 24, the uncertainty surrounding the judging panel adds an element of intrigue. While Bryan’s prediction of Underwood’s return seems promising, his own indecision leaves room for speculation. Lionel Richie’s status also remains unconfirmed, though there’s no indication he’s considering leaving. The show’s history of switching up its judges—seen with departures like Katy Perry’s in 2024—suggests that change is always a possibility.
For fans, the wait for official announcements about the judges and the premiere date continues. Auditions are expected to begin soon, which typically signals that the judging panel will be finalized. Until then, Bryan’s comments offer a glimpse into the behind-the-scenes dynamics of American Idol, where even veteran judges like himself are kept on their toes. Whether the Season 24 panel features the familiar faces of Underwood, Bryan, and Richie or introduces new blood, the show’s legacy of discovering talent and delivering heartfelt moments is sure to endure.
Conclusion
Luke Bryan’s candid remarks about his uncertain future on American Idol and his confidence in Carrie Underwood’s return have set the stage for an intriguing lead-up to Season 24. As the show prepares to premiere in 2026, fans are left wondering whether Bryan will continue his eight-year tenure or step aside for a new chapter. Underwood’s likely return, fueled by her enjoyment of the role and her deep connection to the Idol legacy, is a promising sign for the show’s continuity.
With the judging panel’s chemistry, the mentorship of young talent, and the ever-evolving landscape of reality television, American Idol remains a cultural touchstone. As we await further updates, one thing is clear: the heart of Idol lies in its ability to adapt, inspire, and keep us guessing.
- Luke Bryan’s Uncertain Future on American Idol as He Predicts Carrie Underwood’s Return - August 2, 2025
- The Uniqueness of Miranda Lambert’s Setlists on the I’m the Problem Tour: A Journey Through Country Music’s Heart and Soul - July 29, 2025
- Want to Rave in Zac Brown Band Songs? Book Your Tickets for the Las Vegas Sphere Residency and Check Out the Setlist! - July 17, 2025
